Skip to main content

RD vs SIP: Which Is Better for Monthly Savings?

Post office RD at 6.7% vs an equity SIP: the maturity maths, TDS on RD interest, real Nifty 50 SIP outcomes, and when each one suits your goal.

Beginner9 min readUpdated
By Kousigan A · Learn. Share. Grow together.

A recurring deposit gives a fixed, known maturity; a SIP gives market-linked returns that can beat or trail it. At the post office's 6.7% RD rate for October to December 2026, ₹5,000 a month for five years matures to ₹3,56,829. A SIP at an assumed 10% would reach ₹3,90,412, with no guarantee.

Ganesh, the engineering student who earns a few thousand a month from his YouTube channel, saves about ₹2,000 of it. His father wants that in a post office RD. "Fixed rate, government scheme, no tension." Ganesh wants a Nifty 50 SIP, because he's read about compounding. They're both partly right, and the right answer depends on when Ganesh needs the money. Here's how to decide.

Important Disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only and isn't personalised financial advice. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, and past returns don't guarantee future returns. SIP figures at assumed rates are illustrations, not forecasts. Consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before investing.

What's the actual difference between an RD and a SIP?

Recurring deposit (RD):

A bank or post office deposit where you pay a fixed amount every month for a fixed term and receive a maturity amount set by the interest rate on the day you open it. The rate doesn't change for that account, whatever happens to rates later.

A SIP is a standing instruction to buy mutual fund units with a fixed amount every month. The amount you put in is fixed. What it becomes isn't.

So the trade is simple to state. An RD swaps return for certainty. A SIP in an equity fund swaps certainty for a higher expected return. Which one should you give up?

How is RD maturity calculated?

A post office RD compounds quarterly while you deposit monthly. Each instalment earns interest compounded every quarter for the time it stays in. Here's the formula for that convention:

M = R × [(1 + i)^n − 1] ÷ [1 − (1 + i)^(−1/3)]
R = monthly deposit, i = annual rate ÷ 400, n = number of quarters

I checked this against the post office's own numbers. The National Savings Recurring Deposit Scheme, 2019 prints the maturity value of a ₹100 account: ₹7,231.38 for accounts opened at 7.2% and ₹6,969.67 at 5.8%. The formula gives exactly those figures to the paisa. At today's 6.7%, it gives ₹7,136.58 per ₹100 of monthly deposit. Bank RDs set their own terms, so check your bank's compounding before you compare.

Post office RD at 6.7%: ₹5,000 a month for 5 years

Monthly deposit: ₹5,000. Term: 60 months (20 quarters). Rate: 6.7%, compounded quarterly.

Maturity: ₹3,56,829. Total deposited: ₹3,00,000. Interest: ₹56,829.

Check: ₹7,136.58 per ₹100 × 50 = ₹3,56,829.

The 6.7% is official. The National Savings Institute's rate history shows 6.7% on the 5-year RD from 1 October 2023 to 30 September 2026, and the Finance Ministry's office memorandum of 30 September 2026 keeps all small savings rates unchanged for 1 October to 31 December 2026.

What would the same money do in a SIP?

Here's the SIP side, using the same maths as the SIP calculator: monthly compounding, instalment at the start of each month.

₹5,000 a month for 5 years: post office RD at 6.7% vs equity SIP at assumed and real returns
ScenarioTotal investedValue after 5 yearsGain
Post office RD at 6.7% (fixed)₹3,00,000₹3,56,829₹56,829
SIP at an assumed 8%₹3,00,000₹3,69,834₹69,834
SIP at an assumed 10%₹3,00,000₹3,90,412₹90,412
SIP at an assumed 12%₹3,00,000₹4,12,432₹1,12,432
Real Nifty 50 index fund SIP, Oct 2021 to Sep 2026₹3,00,000₹3,32,032₹32,032
Worst real 5-year window, Apr 2015 to Mar 2020₹3,00,000about ₹2,65,500a loss of about ₹34,500

Those last two rows are real. I simulated monthly SIPs on AMFI's NAV history for a Nifty 50 index fund (UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund, Direct Growth) and scaled them to ₹5,000 a month. The five years to 1 October 2026 returned about 4% a year, less than the RD. The window that ended right after the March 2020 crash lost money outright.

Over longer periods, the picture flips. In the same data, the median 5-year SIP returned 13.77% a year, and none of the 82 seven-year SIPs since 2013 lost money. That's why the horizon decides this, not the product.

How are RD interest and SIP gains taxed?

RD interest is added to your income and taxed at your slab rate, the same as FD interest.

Banks deduct 10% TDS once the interest you earn from that bank in a year crosses ₹50,000, or ₹1,00,000 if you're a senior citizen. These are the thresholds set from 1 April 2025, now in section 393 of the Income-tax Act, 2025. The threshold applies to the total interest that bank pays you in the year, so FD and RD interest are added together. TDS isn't the final tax. If your slab is 30%, you pay the rest when you file.

Equity SIP gains are taxed per instalment. Units held over 12 months pay 12.5% on long-term gains above ₹1.25 lakh a year (section 198). Units held 12 months or less pay 20% (section 196).

After tax, 30% slab plus 4% cess, all redeemed at 5 years

RD: interest ₹56,829, tax about ₹17,731, you keep ₹3,39,098.

SIP at an assumed 10%: the first 48 instalments are long-term, with a gain of ₹87,060, under the ₹1.25 lakh exemption if you have no other gains that year. The last 12 are short-term, with a gain of ₹3,351 taxed at 20.8%, about ₹697. You keep about ₹3,89,715.

For Ganesh, whose income is below the taxable limit, the RD's tax disadvantage mostly disappears.

Is a post office RD safer than a bank RD?

Both are low-risk, but the backing differs. A post office RD is a central government small savings scheme. A bank RD is a bank deposit, and DICGC insures up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank, covering savings, fixed and recurring deposits, principal and interest together.

A SIP in an equity fund has no guarantee at all. Its value is whatever the market says on the day you sell.

Which is easier to get out of early?

Both let you out, at a cost.

The post office RD runs for five years. Under the 2019 scheme, you can close it after three years, but you'll get the post office savings account rate instead of the RD rate. After one year and 12 deposits, you can take a loan of up to 50% of what you've deposited, at 2 percentage points above the RD rate. The minimum deposit is ₹100 a month, in multiples of ₹10.

Bank RDs are more flexible on term. SBI's RD runs from 12 to 120 months, starts at ₹100 a month, and on early closure of up to ₹5 lakh pays 0.50% less than the rate you opened at.

An open-ended mutual fund lets you redeem any business day. The catch is the price. In a falling market, an early exit locks in the fall.

So which one should you pick?

Pick an RD if you need the money in under about three years for a fixed goal, if you can't stomach a fall in value, or if you're in a low slab and want a certain number.

Pick a SIP if the goal is five or more years away, you can keep investing through a crash, and you'd accept a weaker five years in exchange for a better chance over ten. For goals in between, a SIP in a debt fund is the middle ground. The guide to which SIP fits a 1, 3 or 5-year goal matches fund categories to each horizon, and the debt mutual funds guide covers how those funds work.

Or do both. Ganesh settled on that. ₹1,000 a month goes into a post office RD for his M.Tech application costs and a laptop, and ₹1,000 joins his Nifty 50 SIP, money he won't touch for a decade. His father gets his certainty, and Ganesh gets his compounding. The FD vs mutual fund guide runs the same logic for a lump sum, and the course chapter on compound interest explains why the long-horizon numbers diverge so much.

Sources

  1. National Savings Recurring Deposit Scheme, 2019, National Savings Institute. Minimum ₹100 deposit, five-year term, premature closure after three years (paragraph 8), loan of up to 50% of deposits after one year (paragraph 14), and the maturity table for a ₹100 account used to check the formula.
  2. NSI: National Savings RD Account Scheme and interest rate history. Scheme summary; 6.7% from 1 October 2023 to 30 September 2026.
  3. Office memorandum F.No.1/4/2019-NS, 30 September 2026, Ministry of Finance, Department of Economic Affairs. Small savings rates for 1 October to 31 December 2026 unchanged from the previous quarter.
  4. Income-tax Act, 2025, section 393, Income Tax Department. TDS on bank and post office interest above ₹50,000, or ₹1,00,000 for senior citizens. Also sections 196 and 198 for equity fund gains, and the Finance Act, 2026, First Schedule, Part II, for the 10% rate on interest other than interest on securities.
  5. DICGC guide to deposit insurance. ₹5 lakh cover per depositor per bank, including recurring deposits.
  6. SBI Recurring Deposit. 12 to 120 months, ₹100 minimum, premature withdrawal penalty, checked 18 October 2026.
  7. AMFI NAV history. UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund Direct Growth NAVs, January 2013 to October 2026, used for the real SIP rows.

Key Takeaways

  • A post office RD at 6.7% turns ₹5,000 a month into ₹3,56,829 after five years, fixed on the day you open it
  • RD maturity uses quarterly compounding on monthly deposits; the published formula matches the post office's own maturity tables exactly
  • A SIP at an assumed 10% reaches ₹3,90,412, but real Nifty 50 SIPs have both trailed the RD (2021 to 2026) and lost money (2015 to 2020) over five years
  • RD interest is taxed at your slab every year, with 10% TDS from banks above ₹50,000 of interest; equity SIP gains get 12.5% long-term tax above ₹1.25 lakh
  • Use an RD for fixed goals under about three years and a SIP for goals five or more years out, and split if you have both
Quick Quiz

You open a 5-year post office RD at 6.7%. A year later the rate for new accounts drops to 6.2%. What happens to your account?

Frequently asked questions

Is RD better than SIP?

For goals under about three years, an RD is usually the better fit because its maturity is fixed. For goals five or more years away, an equity SIP has a higher expected return. ₹5,000 a month for five years in a post office RD at 6.7% matures to ₹3,56,829; a SIP at an assumed 10% would reach ₹3,90,412, without any guarantee.

How is RD maturity calculated?

RD interest compounds quarterly on monthly deposits: M = R × [(1 + i)^n − 1] ÷ [1 − (1 + i)^(−1/3)], where R is the monthly deposit, i is the annual rate divided by 400 and n is the number of quarters. This reproduces the post office's published maturity values exactly; at 6.7%, a ₹100 monthly RD matures to ₹7,136.58 after five years.

What is the post office RD interest rate for October to December 2026?

6.7% a year, compounded quarterly, for the 5-year National Savings Recurring Deposit. The Ministry of Finance kept all small savings rates unchanged for 1 October to 31 December 2026, and 6.7% has applied since 1 October 2023. The rate on your opening date applies for the full term.

Is TDS deducted on RD interest?

Banks deduct 10% TDS once the total interest they pay you in a year, FDs and RDs together, crosses ₹50,000, or ₹1,00,000 for senior citizens. These thresholds apply from 1 April 2025 and now sit in section 393 of the Income-tax Act, 2025. RD interest is taxable at your slab rate whether or not TDS is deducted.

Try Our Free Tools

Put what you’ve learned into action with our calculators and courses.

Continue Learning

This guide is part of our Personal Finance course. Start with the related chapter:

The Power of Compound Interest

Related guides