Skip to main content

Direct vs Regular Mutual Fund Calculator

See what a regular plan's higher expense ratio costs against the direct plan of the same fund. Set your SIP or lump sum, the period, the direct plan's return and the expense gap to see both values and the difference.

🇮🇳INR

With the default inputs, ₹5,000 a month for 20 years, the direct plan earning 12.5% a year after costs and the regular plan 1 percentage point less:

Direct Plan Value
₹53,47,598
Regular Plan Value
₹46,69,833
Cost of Regular Plan
₹6,77,765
Total Invested
₹12,00,000

What a regular plan costs on a ₹5,000 SIP

A direct vs regular calculator shows how much less a mutual fund's regular plan leaves you than the direct plan of the same scheme. Put ₹5,000 a month into each for 20 years, with direct earning 12.5% and regular 11.5%, and direct ends at ₹53,47,598, regular at ₹46,69,833. The 1 point gap costs ₹6,77,765.

That's 12.7% of the direct plan's value, gone on the same ₹12,00,000 of instalments. Both plans own the same stocks, run by the same fund manager. The only difference is the regular plan's higher expense ratio, which pays the distributor who sold it. The 12.5% is an assumption, not a forecast, so change it, and the gap, to match your own fund.

Why the cost grows faster than the fee

The expense ratio comes out of the NAV every day, so you never see it as a bill. It shows up as a lower return. The calculator models that directly: the regular plan earns the direct plan's return less the gap, and both run through the same SIP maths as the SIP calculator.

FV = P × [((1 + i)^n - 1) / i] × (1 + i)

P
Monthly SIP, invested at the start of each month
i
Monthly rate: r / 12 for the direct plan, (r - g) / 12 for the regular plan
n
Number of monthly instalments (240 over 20 years)
r
Direct plan's expected return after its own expenses (12.5% by default)
g
Expense gap: regular TER minus direct TER, in percentage points (1 by default)

A lump sum is compounded once a year at the same two rates and added on top. The gap never changes. So why does the cost keep climbing?

Because each year's fee is charged on a balance that's bigger than last year's, and every rupee taken out also loses all the growth it would've earned. On the default SIP, the regular plan is ₹350 behind after year 1, ₹11,389 after year 5, ₹69,186 after year 10 and ₹2,41,660 after year 15. By year 20 it's ₹6,77,765.

Time does most of the damage.

Cost of a regular plan by SIP amount and period

Here's the same 1 point gap on three SIP amounts over 10, 20 and 30 years, with the direct plan at 12.5% and the regular plan at 11.5%. Each row was run through the calculator's own function when the page was built, so it matches what the calculator shows for the same inputs.

Monthly SIP invested at the start of each month, direct plan at 12.5% a year and regular plan at 11.5%, both assumed to hold for the whole period. Illustrative, not guaranteed.
SIP and periodTotal investedDirect planRegular planCost of regularRegular smaller by
₹5,000 for 10 years₹6,00,000₹11,96,907₹11,27,721₹69,1865.8%
₹5,000 for 20 years₹12,00,000₹53,47,598₹46,69,833₹6,77,76512.7%
₹5,000 for 30 years₹18,00,000₹1,97,41,567₹1,57,95,422₹39,46,14520%
₹10,000 for 10 years₹12,00,000₹23,93,813₹22,55,442₹1,38,3715.8%
₹10,000 for 20 years₹24,00,000₹1,06,95,196₹93,39,666₹13,55,53012.7%
₹10,000 for 30 years₹36,00,000₹3,94,83,134₹3,15,90,844₹78,92,29020%
₹25,000 for 10 years₹30,00,000₹59,84,533₹56,38,604₹3,45,9295.8%
₹25,000 for 20 years₹60,00,000₹2,67,37,989₹2,33,49,165₹33,88,82412.7%
₹25,000 for 30 years₹90,00,000₹9,87,07,836₹7,89,77,109₹1,97,30,72720%

Look at the last column. The regular plan ends 5.8% smaller after 10 years, 12.7% after 20 and 20% after 30, whatever the SIP amount. Double the SIP and you double the rupee cost, but the share depends only on the gap and the time.

At ₹5,000 a month for 30 years, the gap costs ₹39,46,145, 2.2 times the ₹18,00,000 you'd put in.

What the size of the expense gap does

A 1 point gap is a round number for the maths. Real gaps vary by fund. When I checked AMFI's TER disclosure as on 30 September 2026, 19 large equity funds charged 0.47 to 0.97 points more a year in their regular plans, and the middle fund sat at 0.71. Smaller funds can go wider: Quantum Small Cap Fund's gap was 1.48 points on the same date.

Here's what each of those gaps costs on the default ₹5,000 SIP over 20 years, with the direct plan at 12.5%.

₹5,000 a month for 20 years, direct plan at 12.5% a year, regular plan at 12.5% less the gap. Gaps from AMFI's regular and direct plan total TERs as on 30 September 2026.
Expense gapWhere it comes fromRegular planCost of regularRegular smaller by
0.47 pointsNarrowest of 19 large funds (AMFI)₹50,16,098₹3,31,5006.2%
0.71 pointsMiddle of 19 large funds (AMFI)₹48,55,818₹4,91,7809.2%
0.97 pointsWidest of 19 large funds (AMFI)₹46,88,693₹6,58,90512.3%
1.5 pointsIllustrative, near a smaller fund's 1.48 (AMFI)₹43,67,865₹9,79,73318.3%

Even the narrowest gap costs ₹3,31,500. At the middle fund's 0.71 points it's ₹4,91,780, and a 1.5 point gap takes ₹9,79,733.

TERs change during the month, so check your fund's current regular and direct TER on AMFI's site or the fund's own page, and enter the difference as the gap.

What an existing ₹5,00,000 regular holding costs

You don't need a new SIP to be paying the gap. If you already hold ₹5,00,000 in a regular plan with a 0.71 point gap, the first year costs about ₹3,550. That's roughly the gap times the value, which is a handy way to estimate it.

It doesn't stay there. Leave the holding alone for 10 years at 12.5% and the direct plan would be ₹99,610 ahead, because the fee is charged on a growing balance every year. Enter the amount as a lump sum with the SIP at zero to run your own.

Why direct plans exist

Direct plans aren't a fintech invention. SEBI created them. Its circular CIR/IMD/DF/21/2012 of 13 September 2012 told every fund house to offer a separate plan for investments not routed through a distributor, with a lower expense ratio that left out distribution expenses and commission, and its own NAV. Fund houses launched them from 1 January 2013.

The portfolio wasn't split. Both plans own the same pool of stocks, which is why the calculator can treat the gap as the only difference between them, and why the two NAVs drift a little further apart every day.

How to tell if your fund is a regular plan

Most people who find regular plans in their portfolio didn't choose them on purpose. Here's how to check:

  • Read the full scheme name on your statement or app. A direct plan says so, as in "Direct Plan - Growth". If it says "Regular Plan", or names no plan at all, treat it as regular.
  • Download your Consolidated Account Statement (CAS) from CAMS, KFintech or MF Central with your PAN and email. It covers every fund house in one PDF.
  • Check the broker or adviser field for each folio. A direct holding shows "DIRECT" or no code. A regular one shows the distributor's ARN code.

Switching from regular to direct, and the tax

Switching sounds like moving between two versions of one fund. For tax, it isn't. A switch from the regular plan to the direct plan is treated as a redemption of your regular units and a fresh purchase of direct units, so any gain is a capital gain in that financial year.

  • Equity fund units held more than 12 months: 12.5% on long-term gains above ₹1,25,000 in a financial year, under section 198 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (Section 112A of the 1961 Act).
  • Units held 12 months or less: 20% on short-term gains, under section 196 (Section 111A of the 1961 Act). Cess at 4% sits on top of both.
  • Each SIP instalment is its own purchase, with its own 12-month clock.
  • No exit load is charged on a switch from the regular plan to the direct plan of the same scheme. AMFI told fund houses to stop charging it in April 2025, and SEBI's master circular of 20 March 2026 says so. A switch into a different scheme, or a redemption, can still attract the normal load.
  • ELSS units can't be switched until each instalment's three-year lock-in ends.
  • A switch moves the units you hold, not the SIP. Cancel the regular SIP and start a direct one separately.

Is the tax worth paying? Say ₹1,50,000 of the ₹5,00,000 holding above is long-term gain and you've no other equity gains this year. Switching it all at once taxes ₹25,000 at 12.5%, which is ₹3,250 with cess, less than the ₹3,550 the gap costs in a single year. Split the switch across two financial years instead and each half's ₹75,000 gain falls under that year's exemption, so the tax is nil if you book no other equity gains.

The cheapest step costs nothing: point new SIP money at the direct plan from the next instalment.

When a regular plan, or a fee-only adviser, makes sense

Is a regular plan ever the right choice? Sometimes. The commission pays for a person. If a distributor genuinely helps you pick suitable funds, keeps you invested through a crash and handles the paperwork, the gap buys something you'd use. That's a fair trade only if the help is real.

The catch is that a distributor is paid by the fund house, not by you. The cleaner way to pay for advice is a SEBI-registered investment adviser (RIA). Under the SEBI (Investment Advisers) Regulations, 2013, an RIA charges you a fee directly and can't take distribution commission on what they recommend, so RIAs usually put clients into direct plans. You pay for the advice openly and keep the lower expense ratio.

If an adviser charges a yearly fee as a percentage of your assets, you can enter that fee as the gap for a rough idea of what it costs over your horizon, and set it against what the calculator says the regular plan costs.

What the calculator assumes

Every figure above rests on a few simplifications. Know them before you plan around the result.

  • Both plans earn a steady return every year. Real equity returns swing, but the two plans swing together, so the gap between them holds up better than either figure.
  • The expense gap stays the same for the whole period. In practice fund houses revise TERs, and SEBI's caps fall as a fund grows.
  • SIP instalments go in at the start of each month at the annual rate divided by 12, and a lump sum compounds once a year, the same as the SIP and lumpsum calculators.
  • The regular plan's return is the direct plan's less the gap and nothing else. There's no tax, exit load or switching in the projection.
  • Inflation isn't counted. Both values are in future rupees, which buy less than today's.

Where to go next

Putting a number on the gap is the first step. Here are the tools and reading that go with this one.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a direct vs regular calculator show?

It shows how much less a mutual fund's regular plan leaves you than the direct plan of the same scheme, because of the regular plan's higher expense ratio. At the defaults, ₹5,000 a month for 20 years with the direct plan at 12.5% and the regular plan 1 point lower, direct ends at ₹53,47,598 and regular at ₹46,69,833. The regular plan costs you ₹6,77,765, 12.7% of the direct value.

How much higher is a regular plan's expense ratio?

On AMFI's TER disclosure as on 30 September 2026, 19 large equity funds charged 0.47 to 0.97 percentage points more a year in their regular plans, and the middle fund sat at 0.71. Smaller funds can be wider: Quantum Small Cap Fund's gap was 1.48 points on the same date. At the middle 0.71 point gap, the default ₹5,000 SIP over 20 years costs ₹4,91,780.

Why does a small expense gap cost so much over time?

Because the fee is charged every year on a growing balance, and every rupee it takes also loses the growth it would've earned. With a 1 point gap at 12.5%, the regular plan ends 5.8% smaller than direct after 10 years and 20% smaller after 30, whatever the SIP amount. On ₹5,000 a month for 30 years, that's ₹39,46,145.

How do I know if my mutual fund is a regular plan?

Check the full scheme name on your statement or app: a direct plan says "Direct Plan" in it, and anything else is regular. For every fund at once, download your Consolidated Account Statement from CAMS, KFintech or MF Central. A regular holding shows the distributor's ARN code in the broker field; a direct one shows "DIRECT" or no code.

Is switching from a regular to a direct plan taxed?

It can be. A switch is treated as a redemption, so equity gains on units held over 12 months are taxed at 12.5% above ₹1,25,000 a year, and on units held 12 months or less at 20%, plus 4% cess. There's no exit load on a switch to the direct plan of the same scheme. On a ₹5,00,000 holding with ₹1,50,000 of long-term gain, switching at once costs ₹3,250 in tax, against about ₹3,550 a year lost to a 0.71 point gap.

Is a regular plan ever worth it?

Only if the distributor's help is real: choosing suitable funds, keeping you invested through a fall, and handling the paperwork. The commission comes from the fund house, not from you. A SEBI-registered investment adviser charges you a fee directly, can't take commission on what they recommend and usually uses direct plans, which is the cleaner way to pay for advice.