Skip to main content

Chapter 1 of 12

Why Insurance is NOT an Investment

Keep insurance and investment separate - the #1 rule.

Beginner8 min readUpdated
By Kousigan A · Learn. Share. Grow together.

Endowment plans, money-back policies and ULIPs try to insure you and invest for you at once, and do both jobs badly. Their real IRR lands around 3.5% to 5%, under FD rates. Buying term insurance and putting the difference into a mutual fund gives you more cover and more money.

Parun had been back from Munich for four months, and the well-wishers had found him.

First it was his uncle Chandrasekhar, actually, everyone called him CS Uncle, who appeared at the family home one Sunday afternoon carrying a plastic folder. Inside: an LIC brochure. CS Uncle sat down, had two coffees, and explained that this particular endowment plan was "very safe" and offered "guaranteed returns" and "also life cover."

Parun smiled, took the brochure, and said he would think about it.

Then it was his neighbour's brother-in-law who sold ICICI Pru policies. Then his cousin's husband from Chennai who was "working with a financial planning firm", which turned out to mean he sold ULIPs.

In Germany, Parun had put 40% of his salary into index funds. The concept of an insurance company also being your investment vehicle struck him as fundamentally confused. But he had not done the actual math yet. So he did.

The results were uncomfortable, not for him, but for the endowment plan CS Uncle was selling.

The Core Confusion: Two Jobs, One Product

Bundled Insurance-Investment Product:

An endowment plan, ULIP, or money-back policy is a product that tries to serve two purposes simultaneously, providing life insurance cover and generating investment returns. In practice, it does both jobs poorly compared to keeping them separate.

Insurance companies figured out something brilliant: if you bundle insurance with investment, people feel less bad about paying premiums. "You're not just buying something that pays on death, you're also saving money!" This sounds great. The math does not agree.

The fundamental problem is that insurance and investment have opposite requirements:

Insurance: You need maximum cover for minimum cost. Term insurance does this.

Investment: You need maximum returns. Equity mutual funds do this over the long term.

When you try to do both in one product, you end up with inadequate insurance and poor returns. Both jobs suffer.

What CS Uncle's Endowment Plan Actually Offered

CS Uncle's brochure showed:

  • Rs 5 lakh life cover
  • Premium: Rs 80,000/year
  • Policy term: 20 years
  • Maturity benefit: Rs 23 lakh (guaranteed) + bonus (if declared, not guaranteed)

Parun worked out the actual return on this:

The Real IRR of CS Uncle's Endowment Plan

Annual premium: Rs 80,000 Policy term: 20 years Total paid in: Rs 80,000 x 20 = Rs 16,00,000 (Rs 16 lakh) Maturity amount: Rs 23,00,000 (guaranteed component only)

Using an IRR (Internal Rate of Return) calculator with these cash flows: Year 0 to 19: minus Rs 80,000/year Year 20: plus Rs 23,00,000

IRR = approximately 3.3% per annum

The Rs 5 lakh life cover meanwhile is laughably thin, inadequate for anyone with dependants.

For reference: SBI's five-year FD paid 6.05% on the rates it set from 15 December 2025, and that's guaranteed too. Inflation in India has averaged 5 to 6% over the long run. An endowment plan at 3.3% IRR is delivering negative real returns, you are losing purchasing power in real terms.

Parun had put 40% into index funds in Germany. Indian equity markets (Nifty 50) have delivered approximately 12 to 14% CAGR over 20-year periods. The opportunity cost of putting Rs 80,000/year into this endowment plan vs an index fund is extraordinary.

The Alternative: Term + Mutual Fund

The financially rational alternative is always the same: buy pure term insurance (for the protection you need) and invest the savings in mutual funds (for wealth creation).

Comparison table: Factor, Endowment Plan, Term + Mutual Fund
FactorEndowment PlanTerm + Mutual Fund
Life CoverRs 5 lakh for 20 yearsRs 1 crore to age 60 (Rs 95L more protection)
Annual CostRs 80,000About Rs 20,000 (term) + Rs 60,000 (MF SIP); all Rs 80,000 into MF after 60
Investment Amount per YearNIL (all goes to insurer)Rs 60,000 in equity mutual funds, Rs 80,000 for the last 4 years
20-year corpus at 12% CAGRRs 23 lakh (guaranteed)approx Rs 49 lakh
Real return post-inflationapprox negative (3.3% vs 5-6% inflation)approx 6-7% real CAGR
FlexibilityLocked in, surrender = heavy lossFully liquid, can stop or withdraw anytime
Tax efficiency80C deduction; maturity taxable if premium exceeds 10% of SALTCG at 12.5% above Rs 1.25L, generally better

Parun is 44, so a Rs 1 crore term plan to 60 costs him about Rs 20,000 a year. Put the other Rs 60,000 into a Nifty 50 index fund at the start of each year, then the full Rs 80,000 once the term plan ends for the last four years, and at 12% CAGR it grows to approximately Rs 49 lakh in 20 years. The endowment plan returns Rs 23 lakh. The difference: about Rs 26 lakh, earned by simply splitting the products.

What about tax? The endowment's Section 80C deduction (Section 80C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, section 123 of the Income-tax Act, 2025) only exists under the old regime. Its maturity is tax-free under Section 10(10D) of the 1961 Act (section 11 read with Schedule II of the 2025 Act) only if the yearly premium stays within 10% of the sum assured. CS Uncle's plan charges Rs 80,000 a year on Rs 5 lakh of cover, 16%, so its maturity would be taxed. The 2025 Act took over on 1 April 2026 without changing these conditions.

The Real Numbers Are Even Worse

The comparison above uses the guaranteed component of the endowment plan. In reality, most LIC endowment plans promise the base sum assured as guaranteed and the bonus as variable. If bonuses underperform (as they often do), the actual IRR can be 3.5 to 4%. The term plus MF approach at 12% CAGR (conservative for 20-year Indian equity) more than doubles the money.

Money-Back Policies: The 'But I Get Money Every 5 Years' Version

Money-back policies pay out a percentage of the sum assured every few years, "survival benefits", while keeping the policy active. The math problems run deep:

The Money-Back Illusion

A money-back policy: Rs 10 lakh sum assured, Rs 45,000/year premium, 25-year term. Survival benefits: Rs 2 lakh every 5 years (at year 5, 10, 15, 20). Maturity at year 25: Rs 2 lakh plus bonus.

Total premiums paid: Rs 45,000 x 25 = Rs 11.25 lakh. Total received: Rs 2L + Rs 2L + Rs 2L + Rs 2L + Rs 2L (maturity) = Rs 10 lakh plus bonus.

You paid Rs 11.25 lakh to get Rs 10 lakh back (plus a bonus that might be Rs 2 to 3 lakh). The IRR on this, accounting for the time value of money, is only about 1.5 to 3%.

And the Rs 10 lakh life cover? Hopelessly inadequate for anyone with dependants.

Parun ran these numbers and felt secondhand embarrassment for the product.

'Guaranteed Returns' Just Means Low Returns

Any financial product guaranteed to pay you a fixed amount in 20 years will, by definition, invest your money in very low-risk assets (government bonds, debt instruments), because anything else is unpredictable. Low-risk equals low returns. The guarantee you are getting is the guarantee of keeping up with inflation very poorly.

When Would a Bundled Product Ever Make Sense?

Genuinely almost never for wealth-building. The narrow exceptions:

  • You have extreme medical conditions that make term insurance very expensive or unavailable: and you still need some life cover
  • You have extreme behavioral issues with investing: you genuinely will not invest the savings and need a forced savings mechanism (though a PPF or NPS would do this better)
  • You are in the very highest bracket and the specific tax structure creates an arbitrage (increasingly rare since the Finance Act, 2023 taxed maturity proceeds of traditional policies issued from 1 April 2023 once total yearly premiums cross Rs 5 lakh)

None of these applied to Parun. He had good health, strong financial discipline, and, though his income puts him in the 30% slab, he was nowhere near the very highest bracket.

How to Say No Politely (Because CS Uncle Will Ask Again)

This is a real problem. In Indian families, the insurance agent uncle is often also the uncle whose son you attended the wedding of, whose wife gave your mom a saree, who helped your family during the time everyone needed help. Saying "your product is mathematically terrible" is not always a realistic option.

Scripts that work:

"I already have a term plan and mutual funds, I'm covered.": True, after Parun buys them. Hard to argue with.

"My CA reviewed it and recommended I keep insurance and investment separate.": Shifts the refusal to a professional third party. Defuses personal tension.

"I need a few more months to sort out my finances first.": Buys time. Use it to actually buy the term plan and then come back with script number one.

"I don't qualify: I need Rs 1 crore of cover but this product only gives Rs 5 lakh.": Technical objection, factually correct, hard to counter without selling you something even worse.

The Best Defense Is a Term Plan Receipt

Once you have actually bought a term plan, show CS Uncle the policy document. "I have Rs 1 crore of cover at Rs 9,500/year. I'm sorted on the insurance side." This shuts down the conversation quickly and politely. He cannot argue that you are uninsured.

What Parun Actually Did

Parun went to Policybazaar, compared plans, and bought:

  • Term plan: Rs 1 crore of cover to age 60, from a large private insurer with a long record of high claim settlement, about Rs 20,000/year
  • SIP started: Rs 20,000/month in Nifty 50 index fund plus Flexi Cap fund (split 60/40)

Total insurance cost: about Rs 20,000/year (about Rs 1,670/month). Quotes vary by insurer. Aggregator nyvo's May 2026 data puts the median for a non-smoking man's Rs 1 crore cover to 60 at Rs 15,852 a year when bought at 40 and Rs 22,008 at 45, with no GST on individual life cover since 22 September 2025. At 44, Parun sits near the top of that range. Buying in his 20s would have cost less than half. Investment: Rs 20,000/month, fully liquid, market-linked.

CS Uncle called once more. Parun sent him the term plan policy document and said: "All sorted, uncle. If you have any ideas on mutual funds, I would love to hear." CS Uncle had no ideas on mutual funds.

Key Takeaways

  • Endowment plans, money-back policies, and ULIPs bundle insurance with investment: both functions suffer
  • The actual IRR of most endowment plans is 3.5 to 5%: lower than FD rates, far lower than inflation-adjusted equity returns
  • Term plus mutual fund always beats bundled products for wealth creation, while providing far more life cover
  • Rs 80,000/year in an endowment plan gives Rs 23 lakh at maturity. The same in term plus MF gives about Rs 20,000 for term cover to 60 and the rest in MF growing to about Rs 49 lakh
  • 'Guaranteed returns' is code for 'very low returns': the guarantee requires investing in low-yield assets
  • To politely decline: buy a term plan first, then show the policy document as proof you are already covered

Want to understand the mechanics of ULIPs in detail, where exactly all the charges go and why the math does not work? Go to ULIP Explained: The Full Breakdown. Or see The Truth About Endowment Plans for the LIC brochure Parun eventually handed back to CS Uncle.

Quick Quiz

Parun pays Rs 80,000/year for 20 years in an endowment plan and receives Rs 23 lakh at maturity. Roughly what annual return (IRR) did he earn?


Deep Dives on This Topic