Skip to main content

ULIP vs Mutual Fund: Charges, Returns and Tax Compared

ULIP charges explained, from premium allocation to an FMC of up to 1.35% plus GST, fund value vs sum assured, and 20-year returns against term plus SIP.

Intermediate12 min readUpdated
By Kousigan A · Learn. Share. Grow together.

For pure investing, a direct mutual fund usually beats a ULIP, because a ULIP stacks several charges: premium allocation, mortality, policy administration and a fund management charge of up to 1.35% a year, with 18% GST on top. A ULIP's one real edge is tax-free maturity, within ₹2.5 lakh of premium a year.

Say Priya's bank relationship manager offers her a ULIP: ₹1 lakh a year, ₹10 lakh of life cover, "market returns and tax-free maturity". It sounds like one product doing two jobs. This guide takes it apart charge by charge, shows what fund value and sum assured actually mean on her statement, and compares the 10-year and 20-year numbers with a term plan plus a mutual fund SIP.

Important disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only. The charge caps below are IRDAI's maximums; actual charges vary by product and insurer, and many plans charge less. The worked examples use stated assumptions, not any real policy. Always read the specific policy's benefit illustration and charge schedule before buying any insurance or investment product.

What Is a ULIP?

ULIP (Unit Linked Insurance Plan):

A life insurance policy that invests your premium in market-linked funds of your choice and pays for the life cover by cancelling units from those funds every month, with a mandatory 5-year lock-in during which the money can't be paid out except on death.

The "best of both worlds" pitch is the core ULIP sales argument. Life cover and market returns in one product, with tax benefits. The problem: combining two things in one product almost always means you pay more for both and get less of each.

ULIP Charges Explained: What Each One Costs

Here's where the money goes, in the order it leaves. The caps are from Schedule I of the IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024, which govern ULIPs sold today.

1. Premium allocation charge. Taken from each premium before any units are bought. IRDAI caps it at 12.5% of the annualised premium in any year. Many online ULIPs charge nothing here; agent-sold plans are more likely to charge it in the early years. Say a plan charges 4%: on a ₹1 lakh premium, ₹4,000 is gone before a rupee is invested.

2. Mortality charge. The cost of the life cover, deducted monthly by cancelling units. It's worked out on your age and your sum at risk, which is the cover minus your fund value. It rises with age: small at 30, much heavier at 50.

3. Policy administration charge. A monthly fee for running the policy, capped at ₹500 a month (₹6,000 a year). Plans vary widely, so check the charge schedule.

4. Fund management charge (FMC). A yearly charge on your fund value, taken through the fund's NAV. It's capped at 1.35% a year for every ULIP fund except the discontinued policy fund, where the cap is 0.5%. GST at 18% is added to it, so a 1.35% FMC costs about 1.59% a year.

How does that compare? On AMFI's 30 September 2026 data, the large Nifty 50 index funds charged 0.23% to 0.29% a year in their direct plans, and that total expense ratio already includes GST. So a ULIP at the cap costs about six times an index fund every year, before any of the other charges.

5. Discontinuance charge. Stop paying or surrender during the first five years and a one-time charge comes out of your fund. For annual premiums above ₹50,000, it's capped at the lower of 6% of the premium or fund value, up to ₹6,000, in year 1, falling to ₹5,000, ₹4,000 and ₹2,000 caps in years 2 to 4, and nil from year 5. For premiums of ₹50,000 or less, the cap is ₹3,000 in year 1. The rest of your money moves to a discontinued policy fund that earns at least 4% a year, and it's paid out only when the 5-year lock-in ends.

Switches, partial withdrawals and other alterations can carry charges too, each capped at ₹500.

ULIP charges at IRDAI's caps vs a direct mutual fund. ULIP caps from the IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024; index fund TER from AMFI's TER disclosure, 30 September 2026.
ChargeULIP (cap or how it works)Direct mutual fund
Premium allocationUp to 12.5% of annual premium; many online plans charge noneNone
Life coverMortality charge, monthly, rises with age and sum at riskBuy a separate term plan at a fixed premium
Fund managementUp to 1.35% a year, plus 18% GST0.23–0.29% a year for large Nifty 50 index funds, GST included
Policy administrationUp to ₹500 a monthNone
Leaving in years 1–5Discontinuance charge up to ₹6,000, then money held until year 5Exit load, often 1% within a year for equity funds

ULIP Fund Value vs Sum Assured: What's the Difference?

Your ULIP statement shows two big numbers, and they're easy to mix up.

ULIP fund value:

The number of units you hold multiplied by each fund's current NAV, after every charge has been deducted, which is what you receive at maturity or on surrender after the lock-in.

The sum assured is the life cover you chose when you bought the policy. IRDAI's minimum is 7 times the annualised premium if you're under 50 and 5 times at 50 or over. To keep the maturity tax-free under Section 10(10D), though, the premium can't exceed 10% of the sum assured, so most plans set it at 10 times.

So what does your family get if you die? Most ULIPs pay the higher of the sum assured and the fund value; some pay both. Either way, it must be at least 105% of the premiums paid.

And what do you get if you live? Only the fund value. The sum assured isn't paid at maturity.

Priya's ULIP after four years

Premium: ₹1,00,000 a year. Sum assured: ₹10,00,000. Fund value after four years: say ₹4,00,000.

If she dies now: her family gets ₹10,00,000, the higher of the two.

Sum at risk: ₹10,00,000 − ₹4,00,000 = ₹6,00,000. Her mortality charge is worked out on this, and it shrinks as the fund grows.

If she surrenders after year 5: she gets the fund value, with no discontinuance charge.

The 10-Year and 20-Year IRR Comparison

Here's what these charges mean in real numbers. Scenario: ₹1 lakh a year invested for 10 years, then for 20.

10-Year Comparison: ₹1 Lakh a Year

Option A. ULIP (equity fund)

Annual premium: ₹1,00,000. Life cover: ₹10,00,000, the 10 times needed to keep the maturity tax-free.

Assumed effective return after all charges: 6–8% a year on premiums paid (an assumption for illustration; the policy's benefit illustration shows its own figure).

Corpus after 10 years: about ₹14–16 lakh. Maturity is tax-free under Section 10(10D) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (section 11 read with Schedule II of the Income-tax Act, 2025), as the premium is within ₹2.5 lakh a year and 10% of the sum assured.

Option B. Term insurance plus a direct mutual fund SIP

Term plan (₹1 crore cover, 30-year-old non-smoker): about ₹9,500 a year. Index fund investment: ₹90,500 a year (₹7,542 a month). Index fund TER: about 0.25% a year. Assuming a 12% gross return, about 11.8% net.

Corpus after 10 years: about ₹17.5 lakh (invested at the start of each year). Long-term capital gains tax at 12.5% on gains above ₹1.25 lakh, paid on redemption. Net after tax: about ₹16.5 lakh.

Life cover: ₹1 crore, against ₹10 lakh in the ULIP.

Over 20 years, the gap compounds. At the same assumptions, the ULIP reaches about ₹40–45 lakh (effective return 6–7%). Term plus mutual fund reaches about ₹71 lakh before tax and about ₹65 lakh after it. That's a gap of about ₹20–25 lakh on the same ₹20 lakh of premiums, with ten times the life cover throughout.

This is the calculation a sales pitch rarely shows. Want to test your own numbers? Run the investment half through the SIP calculator at your own return assumption.

How IRDAI Reforms Changed ULIPs

Before 2010, ULIPs could take a large share of the first year's premium as charges, and the lock-in was only three years. IRDA's circular of 28 June 2010 raised the lock-in to five years, made insurers spread charges evenly across it, capped the gap between the fund's gross and net return, and set minimum life cover.

Those rules have been rewritten twice since, and today they sit in the IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024 and IRDAI's Master Circular on Life Insurance Products of 12 June 2024: the 1.35% FMC cap, the 12.5% premium allocation cap, the ₹500 monthly administration cap, the ₹6,000 discontinuance cap and the 4% minimum return on discontinued policies.

These reforms genuinely improved ULIPs. A 2020s ULIP is far better than a 2005 one. But the structure, protection and investment in one product with two layers of cost, still makes it less efficient than buying both separately.

The Tax Argument: Is the Section 10(10D) Benefit Real?

Section 10(10D) exempts ULIP maturity proceeds from tax, provided:

  • Total annual premium across your ULIPs is ₹2.5 lakh or below (for policies issued on or after 1 February 2021)
  • The premium doesn't exceed 10% of the sum assured

Miss either condition and the ULIP is taxed as a capital asset. The Finance Act, 2025 confirmed this from AY 2026-27: gains on an equity-oriented ULIP that has lost the exemption are taxed like equity fund gains, 12.5% on long-term gains above ₹1.25 lakh. The Income-tax Act, 2025, in force from 1 April 2026, keeps the same conditions in section 11 read with Schedule II. Separately, under the old regime, if you stop paying premiums before five years, the deductions you claimed on them under Section 80C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (section 123 of the Income-tax Act, 2025) are added back to your income.

For someone investing ₹1 lakh a year in a ULIP: yes, the maturity is tax-free.

For a mutual fund SIP of ₹90,500 a year, long-term gains are taxed at 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh a year. But that ₹1.25 lakh exemption resets every financial year, so redeeming in stages keeps a large part of the gain tax-free. The ULIP's tax advantage is real, just smaller than the pitch suggests.

One genuine ULIP advantage: tax-free fund switching. Moving from an equity ULIP fund to a debt ULIP fund within the policy isn't a taxable event. In mutual funds, switching from an equity fund to a debt fund triggers capital gains tax. If you rebalance often, that matters. Most long-term investors rebalance once a year at most, and the tax on that is usually small next to 10+ years of a higher FMC.

When Does a ULIP Actually Make Sense?

Is there a case for one at all? A narrow one.

  1. You have a 15–20 year horizon with certainty. The early-year charges spread out over time. Short-horizon investors lose the most.
  2. Your annual premium is ₹1–2.5 lakh. Within the Section 10(10D) tax-free maturity limit.
  3. You're in the 30% tax bracket. The tax-free maturity is worth more to you.
  4. You value forced discipline. The 5-year lock-in stops early withdrawal. If you'd otherwise redeem a SIP at the first market fall, the lock-in can be a useful behavioural tool.
  5. You've already used 80C through ELSS or PPF. ULIP premiums qualify under 80C too, but only in the old regime.

Even then, run the actual numbers against a term plan plus a direct mutual fund. Don't take anyone's word for it.

Why ULIPs Are Sold So Aggressively

Since the IRDAI (Payment of Commission) Regulations, 2023 removed fixed per-product caps, each insurer sets commission through a board-approved policy within its overall expense limits, and the biggest payout still comes from the first year's premium. On a direct mutual fund, the distributor earns nothing; on a regular plan, a trail commission of roughly 0.5–1% a year. Term plans pay low commissions.

The person selling you a ULIP isn't necessarily dishonest. Many genuinely believe in the product. But the products that pay the most get recommended the most, and the only defence is running your own numbers.

The "Benefit Illustration" You Must Ask For

IRDAI requires every ULIP to come with a benefit illustration showing projected values at two assumed gross returns, currently 4% and 8% a year. It shows the premium, the charges deducted and the fund value year by year.

When anyone shows you a projection, ask: "Can I see the benefit illustration in IRDAI's format?" That's the standard document, not a custom chart.

In the benefit illustration:

  • Check the net yield at 8%: the return left after every charge
  • Compare it with what a direct fund would keep at the same 8% gross, which is 8% minus its expense ratio
  • The difference between the two is the ULIP's whole charge stack in one number
Reading a ULIP Benefit Illustration

Assumptions: ₹1,00,000 a year, 20-year term, 8% assumed gross fund return. Say the illustration shows a net yield of 5.5%.

ULIP: total premiums ₹20,00,000. Maturity fund value at a 5.5% net yield: about ₹36,80,000.

Term plus direct mutual fund (same ₹1 lakh a year): term plan about ₹10,000 a year. The other ₹90,000 a year at 8% gross, 7.5% net of a 0.5% expense ratio, grows to about ₹42,00,000. After long-term capital gains tax at 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh, redeemed at once: about ₹39,00,000. Plus ₹1 crore of life cover against the ULIP's ₹10 lakh.

At 8% gross, that's about ₹37 lakh from the ULIP against about ₹39 lakh after tax from term plus mutual fund, with ten times the cover.

Already Holding a ULIP? What Leaving Costs

If you're inside the first five years, stopping doesn't get you your money. Your fund value, less a discontinuance charge of at most ₹6,000, moves to the discontinued policy fund, and you're paid when the lock-in ends. You have three years to revive the policy instead.

After year 5, there's no discontinuance charge. You can surrender and take the fund value, or keep the policy if its remaining charges are low and you still need its cover. If you do surrender, buy the term cover first. Then see what the fund value could grow to as a one-time investment in the lumpsum calculator.

For the life cover half, read the term insurance guide. If you're new to mutual funds and want to understand fund types before redirecting your premiums, the mutual fund beginner's guide covers direct vs regular plans, NAV and fund categories.

Key Takeaways

  • A ULIP's fund management charge can be up to 1.35% a year plus 18% GST, against 0.23–0.29% for large Nifty 50 index funds in their direct plans (AMFI, 30 September 2026)
  • On top come a premium allocation charge (capped at 12.5%), a mortality charge that rises with age, and an administration charge of up to ₹500 a month
  • Fund value is what you get at maturity; sum assured is the life cover, and the death benefit is usually the higher of the two
  • On ₹1 lakh a year for 20 years, term plus a direct mutual fund came out about ₹20–25 lakh ahead in the example above, with ten times the life cover
  • Section 10(10D) tax-free maturity applies only up to ₹2.5 lakh of yearly premium (policies from 1 February 2021) and 10% of the sum assured
  • Leaving in the first five years costs up to ₹6,000 and locks your money in the discontinued policy fund until year 5
Quick Quiz

A ULIP and a term insurance plus mutual fund SIP invest the same ₹1 lakh a year for 20 years. The ULIP offers tax-free maturity. Which statement is most accurate?


Sources

  1. IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024, Schedule I. Caps on fund management charge (1.35%; 0.5% for the discontinued policy fund), premium allocation charge (12.5%), policy administration charge (₹500 a month), switching and partial withdrawal charges, discontinuance charges by policy year and premium size, and minimum sum assured for linked products
  2. IRDAI Master Circular on Life Insurance Products, 12 June 2024 (IRDAI/ACTL/MSTCIR/MISC/89/6/2024). The 5-year lock-in, benefit illustrations at 4% and 8% gross, the 4% minimum guaranteed rate on the discontinued policy fund and the 3-year revival period
  3. IRDA Circular dated 28 June 2010 (No. IRDA/ACT/CIR/ULIP/102/06/2010). The 2010 ULIP reforms: 5-year lock-in, even spread of charges, caps on charges and minimum cover
  4. Finance Act, 2021. Amendment to Section 10(10D): ULIP maturity taxable if annual premium exceeds ₹2.5 lakh (for policies issued on or after 1 February 2021)
  5. Finance Act, 2025. ULIPs outside the 10(10D) exemption taxed as capital gains from AY 2026-27
  6. Income-tax Act, 1961, Section 10(10D), and Income-tax Act, 2025, section 11 read with Schedule II (in force from 1 April 2026). Exemption conditions for life insurance policy proceeds
  7. IRDAI (Payment of Commission) Regulations, 2023. Board-approved commission policies within expense limits
  8. AMFI, Total Expense Ratio of Mutual Fund Schemes. Direct plan TERs of the large Nifty 50 index funds as on 30 September 2026

Frequently asked questions

Is ULIP better than mutual fund for investment?

For pure investment, a direct mutual fund is usually better. A ULIP deducts a premium allocation charge, a mortality charge, a policy administration charge and a fund management charge of up to 1.35% a year plus 18% GST, while a large Nifty 50 index fund's direct plan charged 0.23% to 0.29% a year in total on AMFI data for 30 September 2026. A ULIP's main edge is tax-free maturity under Section 10(10D), within Rs 2.5 lakh of yearly premium.

What are the charges in a ULIP?

Under the IRDAI (Insurance Products) Regulations, 2024: a premium allocation charge of up to 12.5% of the annual premium, a policy administration charge of up to Rs 500 a month, a fund management charge of up to 1.35% a year (0.5% in the discontinued policy fund), a mortality charge that rises with age and sum at risk, and a discontinuance charge of up to Rs 6,000 if you stop in the first four years. GST at 18% applies on top. Many online plans charge well below these caps.

What is the difference between fund value and sum assured in a ULIP?

Fund value is your units multiplied by the current NAV after all charges, and it is what you receive at maturity or on surrender after the 5-year lock-in. Sum assured is the life cover you chose, at least 7 times the annual premium if you are under 50 and usually 10 times to keep the maturity tax-free. On death, most ULIPs pay the higher of the two. The sum assured is not paid at maturity.

When might a ULIP make sense over mutual funds?

ULIPs can be considered only in specific cases: for HNIs where ULIP maturity proceeds (on total premiums up to Rs 2.5 lakh/year and within 10% of sum assured) are tax-free under Section 10(10D); above that cap they are taxed as capital gains, or when someone absolutely needs the discipline of a 5-year lock-in to avoid premature withdrawals. For most investors, the separation principle applies: buy term insurance and invest the rest in mutual funds.

Try Our Free Tools

Put what you’ve learned into action with our calculators and courses.

Continue Learning

This guide is part of our Insurance course. Start with the related chapter:

ULIPs - Why Most Planners Avoid Them

Related guides