Gold ETF vs Sovereign Gold Bond - Which Wins
Gold ETF vs Sovereign Gold Bond after the 2026 tax change: interest, 12.5% tax on gains, liquidity and availability, and why new gold money now usually goes to ETFs.
For new gold money in 2026, a Gold ETF is usually the better pick. No new Sovereign Gold Bond has been issued since February 2024, and from 1 April 2026 an SGB bought on the exchange is taxed like an ETF: 12.5% on gains after 12 months. Existing SGB holders face a different choice.
You want gold in your portfolio, but not the jewellery, not the making charges, and definitely not the worry of storing it. Good. Gold ETFs and Sovereign Gold Bonds both track the gold price and neither needs a locker. Until 2024 the SGB usually won on paper. That's no longer a given.
Here's how to choose now.
What Changed for SGBs Since 2024
Two things, and together they flip the old answer.
First, supply. The last tranche, SGB 2023-24 Series IV, opened in February 2024. At the post-Budget briefing on 1 February 2025, the Finance Minister answered "Yes, in a way" when asked if the scheme was ending, and the Economic Affairs Secretary called it high-cost borrowing. There's no formal closure notice, but there have been no new issues since, and the government has signalled it won't continue. If you want an SGB today, you buy someone else's on NSE or BSE.
Second, tax. The Finance Act 2026 limited the capital gains exemption, from 1 April 2026, to an individual who subscribed at original issue and held the bond continuously until redemption on maturity. A bond bought on the exchange is taxed even at maturity.
So the SGB's headline edge, the tax-free maturity, only exists now for people who already own bonds from an original issue.
The SGB's Remaining Edge: Interest and No Expense Ratio
The SGB still pays 2.5% a year, credited every six months. A Gold ETF pays nothing and charges a small expense ratio.
But there's a catch for exchange buyers. The 2.5% is on the bond's original issue price, not on what you pay. Gold has risen a long way since most series were issued, so if you pay three times the issue price, your interest is about 0.83% a year on your cost. Still more than zero. Much less than it sounds.
Where the Gold ETF Wins: Liquidity and Availability
A Gold ETF trades on the exchange every trading day, with market makers keeping its price close to the value of the gold it holds. You can sell at 10 am and have cash in the same settlement cycle. You can also buy a few units every month.
Exchange-traded SGBs often trade thin. Prices can sit at a discount or a premium to the gold value, and you might not get a fair price when you want out. Each bond also has a fixed maturity date, which may not match your plans.
Is the extra interest worth that friction? For a lot of people, no.
- Gold ETF: ₹5 lakh becomes about ₹7,01,276 before the expense ratio. The gain of about ₹2,01,276 is taxed at 12.5% plus 4% cess: about ₹26,166.
- SGB bought on the exchange and held to maturity: same price move, same ₹26,166 tax, because the maturity exemption doesn't apply to secondary-market buyers. If the bond's issue price was a third of what you paid, the coupon is about ₹4,167 a year, taxed at your slab.
The SGB comes out a little ahead if you can buy it near the gold value and its maturity fits. The ETF wins on liquidity, price and simplicity.
Tax: The Gap Has Narrowed
This used to be the part where the SGB ran away with it. Not any more, unless you subscribed at issue.
Gold ETF: for units sold from 1 April 2025, gains on units held more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% without indexation. Up to 12 months, they're taxed at your slab rate. Units bought from April 2023 and sold before April 2025 were taxed at slab rate whatever the holding period. That ended for sales from 1 April 2025, when gold ETFs fell outside the "specified mutual fund" definition.
SGB you subscribed to at issue: the capital gain is exempt if you hold to maturity. Early redemption with the RBI from year 5 is widely read as taxable since 1 April 2026; check with a tax adviser before you rely on either reading.
SGB bought on the exchange: taxed like the ETF, at 12.5% after 12 months and slab rate before, whether you sell or hold to maturity.
The 2.5% interest is taxable at your slab rate in every case.
| Feature | Gold ETF | SGB (subscribed at issue) | SGB (bought on exchange) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Can you buy it now? | Any trading day | No new issues since February 2024 | Yes, on NSE or BSE, thin volumes |
| Extra income | None | 2.5% of the issue price | 2.5% of the issue price, lower on your cost |
| Tax on gains | Slab up to 12 months, 12.5% after | Exempt if held to maturity | Slab up to 12 months, 12.5% after, even at maturity |
| Lock-in | None | 8 years, RBI exit from year 5 | None, or hold to the remaining maturity |
| Needs demat | Yes | Optional (can hold in RBI records) | Yes |
| Recurring cost | Small expense ratio | None | None, but you may pay a premium |
So Which One?
It depends on whether you already own SGBs.
If you subscribed to an SGB at issue, keep it to maturity. You still get the tax-free gain, and early redemption is widely read as taxable now.
If you're putting in new money, start with a Gold ETF. It's always available, easy to sell, and taxed at the same 12.5% after 12 months as an SGB you'd buy on the exchange.
Consider an exchange-traded SGB only if it's trading at or below the gold value, there's enough volume to exit, and its maturity date suits you. Then the interest is a small bonus.
Key Takeaways
- No new SGBs have been issued since February 2024; you can only buy existing bonds on the exchange
- From 1 April 2026, the SGB maturity exemption covers only individuals who subscribed at issue and hold to maturity
- Gold ETF gains are taxed at 12.5% after 12 months and at slab rate before, for units sold from 1 April 2025
- An SGB bought on the exchange is taxed the same way as a Gold ETF, even at maturity
- The SGB's 2.5% is on the issue price, so an exchange buyer's yield on cost is lower
- For new gold money, a Gold ETF is usually the simpler and more liquid choice
You subscribed to an SGB at issue and plan to hold it until its 8-year maturity. How is the capital gain taxed?
Gold should be one slice of a portfolio, not the whole thing. To see where it fits alongside equity and debt, read gold investment in India and the deeper Sovereign Gold Bonds guide. If you're weighing safer options for the rest of your money, compare debt mutual funds.
Sources
- Reserve Bank of India, Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme. Interest rate, 8-year tenor, and early-redemption rules.
- Finance Act 2026, amending section 70(1)(x) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (formerly section 47(viic) of the Income-tax Act, 1961). SGB exemption limited to original subscribers who hold to maturity, from 1 April 2026.
- Finance (No. 2) Act 2024. 12.5% rate on long-term gains, 12-month holding period for listed securities, and the narrower "specified mutual fund" definition that takes gold ETFs out of slab-only treatment for sales from 1 April 2025.
- NISM, How Budget 2026 changes Sovereign Gold Bond taxation (2026). Budget 2026 FAQs on premature redemption and secondary-market bonds. nism.ac.in
- Outlook Money, post-Budget briefing of 1 February 2025. The Finance Minister on discontinuing the scheme. outlookmoney.com